So I decided to go back with the shadowline trim, after removing the tape that was beginning to peel off. This time i'm going with paint. I got the Pepboys, get trim paint and my g/f calls me up and i tell her my intent for the afternoon. She tells me to come over so she can help... She ends up doing all the sanding and first layers of paint. She recommends I leave the pieces at her house so that she can finish it and clear coat it.

From the looks of it, it seems that she took over my project...