Last week, fitted Yokohama AVID V4S 225/55/16 all around on BBS style 5 wheels. Love the tires, great in the rain, have not tried in the snow. Fitted Continental ContoExtremes on my Audi A4 and those are excellent tires in any condition (but the vehicle is Quattro). My brother recently fitted BF Goodrich GForce KDW(2)s on his 91 M5, but I think those are primarily a summer tire. He has the new tread pattern.
All tires mentioned are reasonably priced. When I shop for tires, my deal is to pay cash and have the shop waive the tax.
If you're a spirited driver, try any of the 3 I've mentioned.
Let us know what you decide on and your thoughts on the tire.
Support your American Flag Merchant Marine
No BMW at this time, eyeing a 91 318iS. 00 Saab 9-5, 89 Bronco XLT, 05 Kawi Z1k, 00 Ducati 748S Bip