PDA

View Full Version : Thrust arm bolt torque under load? THE SHAFT!



Gene in NC
08-15-2005, 08:35 PM
No wonder thrust arm bushing life is so short.

Bad enough that many if not most are apparently torqued with no load on the suspension. The real deal is much worse.

Bentley specs load of 150lbs on each front seat and center of back seat, 50 lbs in trunk and a full tank Assuming empty trunk and fuel 1/2 full, the "load", even if full load of empty car is on the suspension, is 575 lbs short. Do the math.

One way to get the load is go to Lowes for eleven 50lb. bags of sand @ $2.67 each. If you don't think 575 lbs is significant, take it home in your car. Measure the ride height before and after loading and go for a rip on the way home.

If your service shop doesn't have a stack of sand bags about 5 ft high, or a guarantee of four 150 lb people always in the shop to sit in the car, you're getting screwed.

For DIY, c'mon, get with the program or tell me what's wrong with my analysis.

Jon K
08-15-2005, 09:23 PM
No wonder thrust arm bushing life is so short.

Bad enough that many if not most are apparently torqued with no load on the suspension. The real deal is much worse.

Bentley specs load of 150lbs on each front seat and center of back seat, 50 lbs in trunk and a full tank Assuming empty trunk and fuel 1/2 full, the "load", even if full load of empty car is on the suspension, is 575 lbs short. Do the math.

One way to get the load is go to Lowes for eleven 50lb. bags of sand @ $2.67 each. If you don't think 575 lbs is significant, take it home in your car. Measure the ride height before and after loading and go for a rip on the way home.

If your service shop doesn't have a stack of sand bags about 5 ft high, or a guarantee of four 150 lb people always in the shop to sit in the car, you're getting screwed.

For DIY, c'mon, get with the program or tell me what's wrong with my analysis.


My opinion:

If the OEM designed bushings require that kind of preparation to make a damned torque-spec, to hell with it! Grunt Urethane bushing... preload, nope. Weight in car, nope. Torque it and drive it.

632 Regal
08-15-2005, 09:41 PM
if you drive with 4 people and a full trunk of luggage on a daily basis then thats the way to do it...if its only you in the drivers seat and you feel you have to be real anal about it I guess you could sit in the car during the alignment/torque process...I personally dont think its significant enough to harm parts since I am the primary person in there.

pundit
08-15-2005, 09:43 PM
No wonder thrust arm bushing life is so short.

Bad enough that many if not most are apparently torqued with no load on the suspension. The real deal is much worse.

Bentley specs load of 150lbs on each front seat and center of back seat, 50 lbs in trunk and a full tank Assuming empty trunk and fuel 1/2 full, the "load", even if full load of empty car is on the suspension, is 575 lbs short. Do the math.

One way to get the load is go to Lowes for eleven 50lb. bags of sand @ $2.67 each. If you don't think 575 lbs is significant, take it home in your car. Measure the ride height before and after loading and go for a rip on the way home.

If your service shop doesn't have a stack of sand bags about 5 ft high, or a guarantee of four 150 lb people always in the shop to sit in the car, you're getting screwed.

For DIY, c'mon, get with the program or tell me what's wrong with my analysis.

As I rarely travel with passengers I put 4 x 20kg bags of cement on my drivers seat with 3/4's of a tank of fuel before I torqued up my 750 bushes. ;)

Gene in NC
08-16-2005, 08:10 AM
If Bently specs aprox. 600 lb added to chassis weight before torqueing control arm bushing does that indicate that factory uses that preload in original manufacture? At Spartanburg plant the x5 complete driveline and suspension comes in as a preassembled unit. Something is used for preload.

Beemr750
08-16-2005, 09:56 AM
The trick most mechanics use is: While the car is up on a frame holding lift,just jack-up the individual bottom side strut.High enough to carry the full weight off the front,and torque it then.