GO FISHING, use SLABSAUCE Fishing Attractant
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 11

Thread: OT: reduced oil consumption with 5w20 oil?

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Benneton (United Colors of)
    Posts
    3,067

    Default OT: reduced oil consumption with 5w20 oil?

    first things first, this isn't with any bmw motor, i'm sure that one of those would be clacka-clacka-clacking within two changes if you attempted to use such a light oil in such.

    the vehicle in question is a 1999 ford taurus with 150k miles on it. i was changing the oil on two vehicles with the ford vulcan 3.0 v-6, the aforementioned taurus, and a 1998 ford ranger with 205k miles. i was in a hurry to go over and mow my grandmother's lawn, so i attempted to change the oil in both at the same time. here's where my story starts. i had previously bought a number of bottles of 5w20 quaker state to try out in the taurus, as ford has retroactively approved the use of xw20 oil in vehicles that required an xw30 in 2002. bill r had said something to the effect that he would not bother trying it out on such an old vehicle, and that i wouldn't notice a gas mileage improvement, which was one of the selling points for the stuff.

    in my haste, i accidentally left the drain plug off of the truck whilst refilling it, which caused me to waste 5 quarts of the 10 quarts of the 5w30 necessary to service both vehicle.....long story short, one of the vehicles ended up getting 4.5 quarts of 5w20, as i wasn't in the mood to go back to the store. vehicle was filled up to 1/2 quart below fill mark 4500 miles ago. usual oil consumption was 2/5 -.5 quart between 3000 mile oil changes. checking the level yesterday indicates that the car has used 2/5 of a quart in 4500 miles on 5w20.

    i know that oil makers are not yet technologically advanced enough to make a 20 weight oil that is not semi-synthetic, but even when i was using mobil 1 in this vehicle, i'd still see a consumption of 1 quart per 6k miles. any thoughts or explanations as to why my consumption might decrease with this significantly thinner oil? thanks for spending the 15 minutes to read this.
    "..Torchinski v. Peterson that it is legal to carry a concealed weapon, so long the weapon is totally slick like a huge ass machine gun that you carry under a trench coat, like in the Matrix."


  2. #2
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Chicago, Il. U.S.A.
    Posts
    4,243

    Default

    Accuracy measuring tiny fractions of a quart via the dipstick is dubious at best. Attitude of the car, how long it has sat before checking and oil in the tube all contribute to what the indication is. I suspect the oil consumption hasn't really changed.
    Driving conditions will contribute as much or more to the consumption as such a minor viscosity change.
    I hope you still had a drain pan beneath the car when pouring those five quarts through.
    "The gas pedal wouldn't go to the floor if it weren't meant to be there"

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Benneton (United Colors of)
    Posts
    3,067

    Default

    let me make something clear, in the event that i obscured it with all of my babbling.

    usual consumption is .5 quart per 3k, full crankcase (ie, dipstick goes from F to 1/2 down within 3k, or 1 quart per 6k)

    consumption during this change is apparently 4/10 per 4500 miles, with the dipstick filled to halfway between hashmarks at the oil change (ie, filled halfway, has not dipped to below FILL line) within the last 500 miles. i've checked it about 7 times on 7 different surfaces during the last 500 miles to see if the level would drop enough to require refilling--out of curiousity.

    we've owned the car since it was about 11 months old (a 1999 car put into service in 10/98, purchased by us in 10/99. i have a significant knowledge of the oil consumption of this car. normally, i would have expected to had to add at least .5-.75 quart of oil (because i like to have it topped off) to the car to make it to a 5k oil change on 5w30. driving has been about 1k miles a week, almost entirely 50/50 city highway, for the past ~three months. it was burning more on 5w30 doing this than it is now.


    and yeah, the drain pan was still under there, but my drain pan at my mother's house is a custom job made out of a liquid margarine jug that only holds about 9 quarts. enough spilled out to ruin my day.
    Last edited by ryan roopnarine; 12-30-2007 at 02:39 AM.
    "..Torchinski v. Peterson that it is legal to carry a concealed weapon, so long the weapon is totally slick like a huge ass machine gun that you carry under a trench coat, like in the Matrix."


  4. #4
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    475

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by ryan roopnarine
    ...(because i like to have it topped off)...
    I think this is the key to the 'mystery'.

    You said that on this oil change you left the engine .5 quart shy of full (not normal for this car for many years) as you had better things to do.

    With this lower oil level, could there be less whipping of the oil by the crankshaft; meaning less frothy oil to be more easily burned, either through the PCV system or past the rings?

    The proof of this theory would be to use the 5W-20 on the next oil change and keep the oil topped up as before. If the consumption is less than the old 'normal' with the old 'normal' top-off behavior, then it must be the oil formulation and not my half-baked hypothisys.

    Happy New Year,

    Brian

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Benneton (United Colors of)
    Posts
    3,067

    Default

    that might be it, now that i think about it. i'm going to go to the store tomorrow, buy some of the $2.75/qt synthetic oil that is on sale at advance auto (the xw20) and fill it up all of the way with a change.
    "..Torchinski v. Peterson that it is legal to carry a concealed weapon, so long the weapon is totally slick like a huge ass machine gun that you carry under a trench coat, like in the Matrix."


  6. #6
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Benneton (United Colors of)
    Posts
    3,067

    Default

    i know that nobody cares, but i changed my oil to a full syn 5w30 about a week ago. i thought that valvoline made a syn xw20, and that i would be able to get such on sale for 5.20 for 2 quarts, but no such luck. fyi, the synthetic oils on sale for bogo at advance autoparts are valvoline syn 5w30, 10w30, and 20w50, so they do have something for e34s if one is at all interested in partaking in the sale. anyways, the car has began to suck down the 5w30 as it did in the past. at the next interval, i'll spend the extra couple of bucks to put in a full synthetic 0w20 from mobil 1 and see if the consumption decreases the way it did with 5w20. currently, the car has used about .2 quart on 800 miles of driving.
    "..Torchinski v. Peterson that it is legal to carry a concealed weapon, so long the weapon is totally slick like a huge ass machine gun that you carry under a trench coat, like in the Matrix."


  7. #7
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    475

    Default

    [QUOTE=ryan roopnarine]i know that nobody cares, but i changed my oil to a full syn 5w30 about a week ago. i thought that valvoline made a syn xw20, and that i would be able to get such on sale for 5.20 for 2 quarts, but no such luck. fyi, the synthetic oils on sale for bogo at advance autoparts are valvoline syn 5w30, 10w30, and 20w50, so they do have something for e34s if one is at all interested in partaking in the sale. anyways, the car has began to suck down the 5w30 as it did in the past. at the next interval, i'll spend the extra couple of bucks to put in a full synthetic 0w20 from mobil 1 and see if the consumption decreases the way it did with 5w20. currently, the car has used about .2 quart on 800 miles of driving.[/QUOTE

    So you filled it all the way to 'full' again?

    You know, I remember being told a story where somebody's dipstick was too short, causing high oil consumption due to running the engine with the oil in an over-full condition.

    Do you know where your dipstick has been?

    Brian

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Posts
    235

    Default Try one of these Ryan .................... :)

    These are great....and will save you time (and oil)


    [URL="http://www.quickoildrainvalve.com/"]
    "Uncle" Phil C
    2011 Kia Optima EX-P.
    Former owner of a 95 525i 5spd. "The GQ" aka A Shark in sheeps clothing
    03 R1150RT 6spd. "DaRTth"
    00 R1100R 5spd. "LeRoy"

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    San Jose, CA
    Posts
    267

    Default

    I've always read people say that oil consumption is higher with lighter oil, if you had a consumption problem, because it gets past the rings more easily. So this thread begins to defy what I thought was logical.

    On the previous motor of my E34, I would always fill the thing to the spec'd amount, and it would be full, but without fail it would lose enough oil to read half-way on the stick and then stay there.

    Edit: I use 20w50!
    Last edited by AngryPopTart; 01-17-2008 at 10:54 AM.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Benneton (United Colors of)
    Posts
    3,067

    Default

    brian, i filled it all of the way up because i thought that there was a possibility that rings had become "unstuck" during the interval, and that maybe consumption would remain the same on 5w30. as soon as this car rolls over 1k miles on the change, i'm going to use my marine lube pump to suck the quantity of oil down to 1/2 from full through the dipstick tube. i really don't like leaving the oil level down any on anything that i drive. i don't recall the exact wording of the saying, but there is a saying that says "lube is cheap, parts are not," or something to that effect. i'm curious to see how this goes though. though the shape of the dipstick handle is different, both the truck and the car have the same motor, so i might try the truck dipstick on the car the next time i'm in orlando.


    as to the speed drain valve.....i think that my becoming an old man is going to require one of those soon. too much dropping of plugs into the drain pan and so forth...
    "..Torchinski v. Peterson that it is legal to carry a concealed weapon, so long the weapon is totally slick like a huge ass machine gun that you carry under a trench coat, like in the Matrix."


Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. OT: switch to 5w20 in 200k mile ranger? any thoughts...
    By ryan roopnarine in forum 5 Series BMW
    Replies: 11
    Last Post: 06-20-2007, 04:46 PM
  2. ABS warning light from reduced tyre diameter?
    By genphreak in forum 5 Series BMW
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 11-23-2006, 08:45 PM
  3. OT: Great clearance deal on Redline 5w20 at advance autoparts..
    By ryan roopnarine in forum 5 Series BMW
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 05-11-2006, 06:16 PM
  4. Replies: 6
    Last Post: 02-19-2004, 10:28 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •