Get some nice Kumho's to fit your stock BBS's at tire rack and drive it as a sleeper for awhile. Meanwhile, scout out e34 wheel designs like the tstar or m-parallels that don't require spacing rings and come in 17". Neither the alignment machine nor the balancer can detect a hub spacer ring out of true. Also, the wheel itself may be at fault.
It takes a new suspension a little time and a few italian tune-ups for it to "settle down." Best to let it settle in with some fresh rubber on the stock diameter.
o/______\o
(Oo=00=oO)
[]=****=[]